Saturday, 31 August 2013
Monday, 15 July 2013
Donor interests shaping East African regional integration?
Since its re-establishment in 2000, the
East African Community (EAC) has experienced a surge in Official Development
Assistance (ODA). Between 2005 and 2013, the volume of ODA disbursed to support
the EAC budget increased by 800% from US$8.5 million to US$76.1 million and the
portfolio of donors expanded to constitute over 25 development partners. In the
2013/14 financial year budget estimates, ODA constitutes 65.0% of total EAC
income.
There are concerns that the prominence of ODA in EAC revenue streams
might be negatively influencing the trajectory of the integration process. Article
132 of the EAC treaty requires that the EAC budget be funded by equal
contributions from Partner States. The Secretariat has, however, not succeeded
in sufficiently consolidating such funding. Though contributions from member
states more than doubled between 2005 and 2013, its proportion of the total EAC
budget declined by 21.7% while the share of ODA increased by 21.7% over the
same period. Both the East African Legislative Assembly (EALA) and the
Secretary General of the EAC have cautioned that the continued dependence on donors may deflect the EAC from its primary objectives and urged Partner States
to raise the bulk of funding for the EAC budget in order to remain adequately
in charge of the integration agenda.
" [...] the result maybe and experience shows that it infrequently is, a concentration of operational work on particular themes that correspond more to donor preferences than to overall programme priorities defined at national or international levels ..." (UN Publications)
Studies on resource flows for multilateral
institutions in the past have indicated that whereas ODA significantly expands and diversifies
revenue streams for recipients, it can be exploited to exert influence over
policy, legislative and operational conduct of recipient multilateral organisations. Donors may capitalise
on their patronage to skew operational work to their political and strategic
aspirations thereby failing to align their resources to the priorities of the recipient. This might frustrate effective execution of an institution’s mandate and
undermine the achievement of its core objectives.
The question is:
- What has motivated the surge in donor interest in the East Africa Community?
- How much have donors influenced the conduct of the EAC integration process thus far?
- To what extent has the over reliance on donor support to finance the EAC budget impinged on the ability of the institution to objectively drive through its agenda?
- To what level have donor interests and preferences occupied and and shaped the EAC integration agenda?
- Are there any accountability mechanisms within the EAC framework to manage donor interests?
“ [...] developmental or humanitarian concerns including poverty receive
relatively low or zero weight” when donor motivations for aid delivery are
considered" (Mark McGillivray)
Wednesday, 12 June 2013
Africanising the Open
Government Partnership
My take-aways
from the OGP Africa regional forum
The government of
Kenya recently hosted the first ever OGP regional forum in Africa. The event
aimed to establish guidelines for OGP activities for African countries; track
and take stock of progress on the agenda to date and to strategise how to
Africanise the global OGP movement further. It attracted a range of delegates
from across the continent involved and interested in the pursuit of open
governance - government representatives, civil society actors, academia, the
media, private sector, and multilateral institutions (see
link for details).
“OGP will be real, only when it
starts to make sense to the citizens out there”
(Robert Hunja – World Bank)
Open governance is built on the
principle of the universal right to access to information on the conduct of
government and places its value in enhancing effective public oversight. It
aims to open up government affairs, (previously and normatively kept secret) to
make it easier to scrutinise public officers, identify and hold them to
account. The argument is that access to government information enhances public
participation and facilitates the audit of government actions. The Open
Government Partnership (OGP) is
a new multilateral global governance and transparency initiative incepted in
2011. It aims to secure commitments from governments to promote transparency,
empower citizens and harness new technologies to strengthen governance. The OGP
outlines a set of principles augmented by a declaration that
form the basis of the open government. To date 45 countries (three
African) have endorsed the declaration, 11 others (two African) are currently
processing commitments and many more across the globe working towards
attaining eligibility.
At the heart of the event was the question of
how different partners could together put in place a strategy to strengthen
open governance in the continent and bring forth an African perspective to the
global OGP movement. Participants shared their experiences in the push for
open and transparent institutions accountable to the people and brainstormed
ideas on how the global OGP could respond. Discussions focused on: the role of
big data, public statistics, analytics and technology in improving service
delivery; managing extractive industries to ensure processes are open,
transparent, participatory and accountable; and how to leverage technology and
the media to bolster citizen engagement and enhance public integrity. Key
issues emerging from the discussions included:
- Inadequate understanding of the concept of
open governance in Africa
- The impact of the technocratic language often
used by OGP practitioners and how it fails to resonate with people at
local level
- The lack of engagement amongst African
leaders/governments and failure to share experiences
- The absence of strong champions for the agenda
- The apparent overlap in governance monitoring mechanisms
(OGP, African Union and United Nations, African Peer Review Mechanism etc
) and how this could be stifling progress
- The need to explore both supply and demand
side issues in scaling up OGP
- The quality of information coming forth
through existing open governance platforms
- The inadequate engagement of African
legislatures and private sector who have great influence, political muscle
and interest in good governance in the continent.
Civil Society – Government
disconnect
Participants made the point that
success of the OGP depends largely on trust and cooperation between government
and civil society. Nonetheless, deliberations over the two day conference
illustrated the clear tension between government and CSOs that must be
addressed if we are to achieve meaningful progress.
There is currently a clear
disconnect between the motivations, intentions and expectations of civil
society and that of government despite both working towards the common good of
the citizen. Much work related to open governance appears to be taking place in
silos with little coordination, mutual awareness and strategy. Though the
need for effective partnerships between government and CSOs was emphasised,
participants cautioned against very cosy relationships that create complacency
and that could potentially jeopardise the watchdog role played by civil
society.
“The era of sloganeering, CSO
obstruction, political activism is gone [...] CSOs must reorient and repackage
their engagement with government [... they] must begin to perceive themselves
as partners with government” – (Fred Matiang’i, Cabinet Secretary for ICT –
Kenya)
The African OGP steering committee
must support states and civil society to collaborate with sufficient space for
objective and constructive CSO monitoring and feedback in the role of ‘critical
friend’. This will ensure better delivery and further progress in open
governance.
Transforming commitments into
action
It is encouraging that three
African states are already members of the OGP, two others are processing
commitments and a couple of others are eligible and looking to submit
applications for membership. However, real success of the OGP will depend on
implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the action plans developed by participating
countries. Otherwise OGP membership risks being viewed as an end (utilised to
score political mileage in the global political economy) rather than a means
towards a greater goal of actualising good governance; transparent and
accountable government institutions.
The OGP support unit must play an
active role in monitoring participants to ensure they invest sufficiently in
open governance, set realistic goals in their action plans, implement and
accurately report on progress. Further, it must .safeguard against monopolisation
of the process by government (capable of overstating progress and being
overambitious in planning) and minimising dialogue between CSOs and government
The African experience must, in turn, inform the wider movement.
Thursday, 2 May 2013
The 14% minimum wage announcement on Labour Day just reveals the folly of the man in charge
No country with unemployment rates higher than 25% can afford the luxuries of 'minimum wage'. Increasing the minimum
wage does not make economic sense for a third world economy with over 45%
poverty, 40% unemployment, and without substantive government revenues.
Frankly, the government of Kenya
does not have the economic muscle to invest in public works projects that can
then allow them to dictate wages. They must negotiate effectively with the
private sector and trade unions in order to have a workable formula. In
principle the 14%, thrashed down the throats of the private sector will in the
long run crowd out investment and exacerbate unemployment.
The typical urban poor should not
rejoice in the 14% announcement. Why? This is nothing
more than populist PR stunts that will neither increase employment nor improve
the conditions of existing ones. See, the Kenya Association of Manufacturers already
expressed their dissatisfaction and I won’t be surprised if KEPSA follow
suit.
What you need to address
unemployment especially for the young, average skilled or semi-skilled is labour
intensive manufacturing like in apparel making (shoes, clothing etc) or electrical
and electronics. These require little skill. Employers can thus afford to absorb
a lot of labour (at a cheaper cost) while still managing to maintain sufficient
turnovers. When you dictate the minimum wage – you simply telling these folks
and the many others looking to come invest in Kenya to move elsewhere. The
options are many. What such investors need is a cheap labour and a conducive business
environment - that is precisely what those in government should busy themselves with; not
unilateral populist announcements.
Mr. President Sir, that decision
is bad for business, bad for investment, bad for national income, bad for
unemployment and bad for poverty reduction. What you need is an effective
tri-partite mutual agreement between government, private sector and trade unions
to meaningfully improve wages while still maintaining an attractive,
competitive business/investment environment in Kenya.
Okwarohztake: That 14% announcement just reveals the folly
of the man in charge
Sunday, 28 April 2013
The Judiciary demands justice from Kenyans. How
absurd?
It
is a pity that the Chief Justice of the republic of Kenya,
is now too worried about sentiments of Kenyans on the conduct of the Judiciary
to the extent that he has contemplated libel litigation.
Is
this the same Mutunga that many Kenyans defended tooth and neck (with all his
sneaky paraphernalia) in appreciation of his skill, education and resolve to
transform the legal landscape, promote justice and enhance democracy in Kenya?
Of
all the people, Dr Willy Mutunga should be the most worried about the pertinent
issues Kenyans are raising about the handling of the Presidential election
petition that he presided over. For me, what should worry Mutunga most is the
fear of the loss of the little optimism and faith Kenyans were gradually
developing in the country's otherwise 'legitimacy and credibility bankrupt
Judiciary'.
Instead
of facing these issues soberly and with the seriousness they deserve. The CJ
has flipped the coin and put Kenyans on the receiving end. Now: 'THE JUDICIARY DEMANDS JUSTICE FROM
KENYANS! How awkward? Read this epistle from Dr Willy Mutunga http://on.fb.me/12TIkIc.
Of
all the agenda 4 items on the transformation of Kenya after the 2007/08 Post
Election Violence - the Judiciary remained the beacon of hope (I’d like to
believe it still is) in terms of progress.
Dear
Mutunga, kindly, do not serve Kenyans with another activist public servant like
PLO Lumumba did. The stature of your job and the perks that come with it
obviate the plethora of comfortabilites and nicities that you are demanding.
Yours is a hard job, to deliver a reformed judiciary to thankless Kenyans at a
time when the country is most polarised. Quit whining and provide answers to
the errors and omissions that we have 'accepted and moved on' about. Deliver us
a credible judiciary.
Otherwise
some Kenyans will resign to the knowledge that the many we hold with high
regard before appointment - the likes of Kivuitu, PLO, Isaak Hassan etc,
will perform dismally, screw us up and turn up to blame and spit on us for
their ineptitude. This is a big test on MERITOCRACY Sir.
Saturday, 13 April 2013
The folly of a ‘non-nation’
Dear Kenyan
on social media,
Yes,
you there, super-sharing those pictures of Raila, Uhuru, Kalonzo and Ruto at
statehouse. Here is free counsel, in African politics (actually all polities)
there is no such thing as a truce, just episodes and interludes of re-strategising,
undercutting, callousness, malice and 'smile-angering'.
If you believe those 4 politicians giggling like
sorority girls in front of statehouse, you are the fool. It will take way more
than handshakes and smiles to meaningfully make Kenya the one nation we desire
- maybe we have never been at all (goodness me).
After all didn’t Kibaki and Raila shake hands
and have tea in front of Harambee House in 2008 after presiding over
the killing of over 1000 Kenyans and displacement of hundreds of thousand
others? Didn’t we still end up with two nations baying for each other’s blood
in 2013?
'Move on' (this is officially a swear word around
me) if you like, disregard the serious deficiencies of nationalism that we face
today, sweep them under the carpet ... but be sure we will be back at it soon,
back to fire fighting - once stuff has exploded. Kenyans never
disappoint.
Many thanks
Okwaroh
Okwaroh
![]() |
| 2008 |
![]() |
| 2013 |

Tuesday, 12 March 2013
Taking over the African narrative
What I said at the Africacounts round table in Kampala, Uganda
What I said at the Africacounts round table in Kampala, Uganda
In Africa today, interesting and
indeed intriguing processes and events are unfolding that are gradually but
profoundly shaping the conduct of the political economy and developmental
trajectories of the continent. These present significant prospects and
challenges for the regions prosperity and stability
Economic growth: Today, Africa is home to some of the fastest growing
economies in the world. Uganda’s economy grew at an average 7% annually
throughout the past decade (1999 – 2011).
Ghana, Nigeria, Angola, Kenya are now some of the hottest growth markets
in the globe. Africa is positioning herself as the 21stC go to investment
paradise. The number of investors flocking departments of trade and industry,
energy, and finance in Mozambique, Angola, Tanzania, Kenya, South Sudan and
many other African states is testimony to that reality.
Emerging global market: In terms of demographics, Africa
is now home to a huge dynamic population; an expanding middleclass with substantive
purchasing power and increasing consumerism. Africa is emerging as a global
market that can no longer be overlooked.
Governance: We have made great progress towards accountability
and good governance. Several Sub-Saharan countries are reforming their
governance systems and inching towards effective constitutionalism, rule of
law, open governance, citizen participation, transparency and accountability. Kenya
is testing the products of institutional reform in the past five year; Rwanda
is reaping the benefits of good governance; and South Sudan is on course
towards building a strong state buttressed by modern day democratic
institutions. African states are increasingly experiencing civilised political transitions
and a new generation of African leaders are stepping up to change the facade of
Africa’s political economy. These are developments that cannot be overlooked!
Internalising our externalities: Gradually, African states are recognising
the value of maximising the advantages of pooling their sovereignty and moving
towards supplying regional public goods. Different states West, South and East
of Africa are courageously confronting the challenges and demands for regional
cooperation, and are making encouraging progress, delicately weaving the wafts
and wefts towards achieving ‘African-multilateralism’ based on the appreciation
of the mutual benefits of internalising our externalities.
Closer home, East Africa is making giant strides toward strengthening
the East African Common Market Protocol and pushing for higher stakes in the
East African Community. The discovery of oil and gas in Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania
positions East Africa as one of the largest gas producers in Africa and a major
global player in oil production in subsequent decades. However continued conflict and political
instability amongst the region’s neighbour’s remains a challenge. State
fragility in South Sudan, delicate transition in Ethiopia, insurgencies in the
DRC and the Somali crisis ... Moreover, there still persists a lingering
spectre of poverty: East Africa has nearly 73% of the population in
multidimensional poverty and is home to some of the world’s poorest nations,
Burundi for example.
Taking charge: It is time to take charge of the African narrative
and it begins with shaping the objects of the story. As we demand that Africa
gets its fair share of attention and participation in global governance
discourses, we must equally endeavour as states and as individuals to invest substantively
producing evidence – new knowledge and using it to inform and shape our
engagements between citizens, policy makers, media, civil society and academia.
Africa must take an account of our resource endowments, recognise our challenges
and appreciate the progress we’ve made. This must be effectively communicated
to the globe – that Africans are capable and indeed ready to confront their
ills and chart a sustainable path towards restoring our dignity and claiming
our fair share of the earth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










