Showing posts with label Poverty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Poverty. Show all posts

Thursday, 19 June 2014

THE SPARKS FOR IGNITING THE DATA REVOLUTION

The data revolution should include a universal legislation requiring states to provide open, good quality data


Ever since the release of the High Level Panel report on the Post 2015 development agenda in 2013, the concept of a data revolution has gained significant traction in conversations at the global level. Nonetheless progress towards actualising the revolution in practical terms remains hamstrung by data sourcing and a myriad other challenges that can potentially be dealt with by an internationally-led consensus and sustained momentum to bring multiple stakeholders on board, and work closely with governments on issues of accessibility and usability of good quality, timely and relevant data and information.

  

I have participated in forums discussing the idea of the data revolution. I have also engaged in related conversations that seek to leverage the use of data and information for better policy making, governance and service delivery like the Open Government Partnership (OGP), the International Aid Transparency Initiative (IATI) and the Open Data movements. A lot has been achieved towards outlining what is meant by the data revolution, of course with diverse and sometimes divergent views, what we want to achieve with it, and what obstacles remain on the way towards realising it.

  

The World Bank has sponsored elaborate conversations on the data revolution both in international forums and within localised national level facilitated processes. The Oversees Development Institute (ODI) as well through the Post 2015 blog has sponsored a series of research work and literature on the nature and impetus behind the data revolution. The PARIS 21facilitated an event on the sides of the UN General Assembly in 2013 on engineering a development data revolution. Elsewhere Civil Society Organisations are organising a broad range of stakeholders in many countries to make sense of the data revolution and what developmental ends could be achieved from it. In East Africa Development Initiatives is engaging an ecosystem of data handlers to discuss how to make sense of and utilise the data revolution to end poverty.

  

There is near consensus that the data revolution must be underpinned by a focus on providing open data, that is of good quality – available in machine readable formats and up to date.


However, the common narrative about what impedes the data revolution seems to rest on source challenges emanating from the supply side. These apply both in developed and developing countries. The argument is that even before discussing what to do with the data and how to make it relevant to poverty reduction in order to resonate with lives of common citizens, we need to locate the data. Data providers on the other hand lament that whatever is made available, no matter how little, is not being used. So where do we stand?


I am persuaded that unless these sourcing and usability of currently available data issues are resolved there will be significant challenges in realising the data revolution.

Across the globe, the approaches to data sourcing and tackling usability challenges vary, with similarities in certain instances. Some are using national level legislation or policies to compel custodians of development data to make it available to the public, while some are using laborious and expensive processes of purchasing and digitising data that is not available in machine friendly formats. But these approaches have achieved very little since, governments - custodians of the largest proportion of development data either lack the incentive, political will, or legal frameworks to make data available.


We now know that many interventions and programmes being implemented globally and at national levels are based on poor quality data or statistics that make them tenuous and contestable.  Yet for over a decade, enormous resources have been allocated and programmes implemented to tackle development challenges. African economies are suddenly leaping into middle income status due to revisions in national statistics and introduction of data previously not considered in calculating important national development indices.


The current development data isn’t good enough. Nearly 40% of developing countries cannot measure their poverty trends over the last decade due to inadequate data. The HLP report on post 2015 development agenda and UN Secretary General’s report on poverty both call for pioneering approaches to improving quality, timeliness and relevance of development data and a fundamental rethinking of the way we use data for social good” – Dr Jim Yong Kim, World Bank President.


I am of the opinion that now more than ever, the data revolution requires an international level facilitated process, to require national governments to make good quality data available to the public. Such a process could drive country level action by multiple stakeholders to invest in producing data and translating it to usable information.


This has been achieved in other spheres, for example the declaration on human rights was ratified globally compelling states to abide by and guarantee a minimum set of rights for all their citizens.


Through diplomacy and international driven consensus, development practitioners can lobby for a similar international declaration, or better yet, a standalone goal in the post 2015 framework to guarantee access to information to all citizens across the world. This could provide the much needed leverage that actors at national levels pushing for increased access to development data can use to further the agenda of the data revolution


This blog was originally posted on Open Development Toolkit here:  http://opendevtoolkit.net/en-US/blog/sparks-igniting-revolution/ 



Tuesday, 8 October 2013

A ‘data revolution’ for elimination of poverty?


Inherent in the 2013 High Level Panel (HLP) report on the Post 2015 Development Agenda is the idea of a ‘data revolution’ that aims to draw on existing and new sources of data to infuse statistics into decision making[1]. The ultimate is to have information shape policy: to encourage open access to data, facilitate relevant analysis and to promote appropriate employment of accrued information to improve policy.

“Too often, development efforts have been hampered by a lack of the most basic data about the social and economic circumstances in which people live. Stronger monitoring and evaluation at all levels, and in all processes of development [...] will help guide decision making, update priorities and ensure accountability. [...] We must also take advantage of new technologies and access to open data for all people.” ~ Bali Communiqué of the High-Level Panel, March 28, 2013
The conceptualisation of the ‘data revolution’, albeit not universally agreed on so far, leaves the connotation of an overhaul of the current system[2]. It implies empowering citizens (CSOs, media, government officers, ‘techies’, academicians and development partners within a data ecosystem) in a ‘fresh wave’ of data collection, analysis and use. It is a call for transparency and accountability[3]. It aims to ensure that information influences development policy; that data is utilized to evaluate the efficacy of policy and that data provides feedback loops for improvement of systems, institutions or policies. The question that lurks however is:

Will a ‘data revolution’ or its equivalent really lead to better policies and attainment of poverty eradication targets beyond 2015?
Clearly better data and improved evidence has proven to be able to facilitate better policy making. A data revolution, if conceptualised as so, would thus provide the factual basing for the review and improvement of policy to meet the demands of prevailing circumstances. However, there is also the risk of getting overly carried away with datasets and infographics, and losing focus on the structural issues that require to be addressed in order to improve policy and bolster poverty reduction. 

The real 'data revolution' will depend on the ability to collect and aggregate data, and to have as many people as possible collabortaing effectively around a distributed ecosystem of information[4]. Conversely, a non-revolution would be a kin to having just a 'select group of nerds or politicians knowing more about poor people and their problems'[5].
  • What should be the true understanding of a ‘data revolution’ in the context of poverty reduction?
  • What is the potential for a ‘data revolution’ to contribute to development and to the ending of poverty by 2030 and what could stop this from happening?
  • What role can different stakeholders in the data ecosystem play in promoting the ‘data revolution’?
  • What could best inform the design of a platform to drive the ‘data revolution’?


Monday, 3 December 2012


When poverty reduction competes with state building: 

The case of South Sudan

The world’s youngest nation, South Sudan, has now had over a year of political economic autonomy, following a break away from Sudan in July 2011. Independence was preceded by the period after the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement in 2005, during which it operated as a semi-autonomous government. South Sudan has since made significant progress in restoration of peace, political transition, establishment of governance structures towards building a stable state. There have also been improvements in the socio-economic wellbeing of the people of South Sudan.

However, this has not been without challenges some of which could negate the progress already made. Preliminary analysis on public expenditure and resource flows reveals critical resource management challenges that could have far reaching implications on fiscal sustainability, public accountability and the economic well being of the country’s poor.

Despite significant data limitations and methodological constraints, Kenneth Okwaroh analysed the flow of domestic revenues and Official Development Assistance (ODA) in South Sudan.  He used budget estimates for the period between 2006 and 2011 as a proxy to analyse the intentions, motivations and the character of resource allocation in the country with a specific focus on resource allocations for poverty reduction. The analysis revealed the following:

Acute dependance on oil revenues 
I – The Government of South Sudan (GoSS) acutely depends on oil revenues for its income. Between 2006 and 2011, oil revenues contributed over 98% of state income. This poses a risk to fiscal sustainability especially because the country’s oil production is projected to decrease by 10% by 2019, and by 50% by 2029 if no new reserves are discovered. This lack of diversity in the economy, together with increasing dependence on imports, increases the country’s vulnerability to fiscal turmoil in the face of external shocks. A classic example is the decision to shut down oil production in response to the dispute with Khartoum that lead to unprecedented inflation rates (80% in May 2012) and profoundly stifled growth. Besides undermining sound -economic management such dependence on oil revenue also impedes effective taxation with significant implications for governance and accountability.

Competing resource demands - Poverty missing out
II – Since the signing of the CPA in 2005, the country has experienced considerable growth in state revenues and ODA flows. However this has not been translated into significant progress in human development, poverty reduction and economic growth. Compared to other states in the East African region, South Sudan has the lowest life expectancy at birth (42 years), lowest adult literacy levels (27%), highest maternal mortality rate (2,054 per 100,000 live births) and one of the highest poverty headcounts (51%). Given these high poverty and welfare indicators, and the direction of government expenditure, it is deducible that, key priority areas for budget allocation are not efficiently and effectively aligned poverty reduction outcomes.

III – South Sudan could be struggling with mechanisms for balancing resource demands for state building with the urgent need to address poverty and human development. Despite government revenues and expenditure steadily expanding, pro-poor sectors such as agriculture, health and education, have been considerably under-funded. For example while state revenues expanded by 17.2% between 2008 and 2012, total expenditure on agriculture, education and health as a proportion of total spending grew by only 11.7%. These three sectors, which were identified as expenditure priorities, collectively received 12.5% of total average spending, compared with security, which received 28.2%. Conversely, public administration and justice, law and order, which were not considered priority sectors, reported higher outturns (11.5% and 11.4% respectively). Moreover expenditure in all three sectors fell short of international standards and targets set by peer states.

Prioritization far from actual spending
IV – There are significant gaps in the alignment of resources with identified expenditure priorities. Both budget allocations and donor commitments are not adequately synchronised with these priorities. For example, the education and health sectors, which the GoSS outlined as priority expenditure areas, received lower proportions of total spending (6.9% and 4.2% respectively) than public administration (11.5%) and rule of law (11.4%), which were not identified as priority sectors.
Okwaroh argues that the findings depict a largely unstable macro-economic environment that least guarantees fiscal sustainability, steady public revenues and predictable public spending. There is compelling evidence that abundant oil revenues in South Sudan coupled with aid could be impinging on effective domestic tax collection. With a small underdeveloped and less diversified formal economy, low capacity government institutions and inefficient tax collection, it risks becoming an import-dependent country afflicted with the ’resource curse’.  Fluctuating GDP growth and instability in the oil industry add to the fragility of a conflict-ridden state, faced with multiple resource demands for reconstruction, state building and poverty reduction. South Sudan must therefore streamline its management of oil and explore alternative, non-oil resource streams – such as agriculture – to ensure fiscal sustainability. It must institute mechanisms to ensure effective balancing of resource demands for state building with funding for poverty response. 

You can find the full report here:  and the data and analyses here: 

Tuesday, 14 August 2012


 Olympics: Far from the shiny stuff you see on telly  

When I heard Kenya’s Prime Minister declaring at the Kenya House in Stratford that the country would be bidding for Olympics 2024 – I wondered what a heavy load of folly. I wondered what deludes an African state bedevilled with corruption and inept financial management and oversight mechanisms like Kenya that they would pull off a mega event when big gunners like Canada, UK, Australia, and South Africa could not even come close to recovering their investment.

Well, for the past fortnight, the Olympic mood engulfed Great Britain. London has been awash with emotions, revellers and Olympians alike. True to the words of Mayor Boris Johnson: London went ‘Zoink’. But hang on a minute, who really were the folks sucked into this Olympic-frenzy? Who indeed were the real winners? Could there have been someone somewhere on the curbs, standing on the side-lines bypassed by the Olympo-mania? There has been some over-optimism and naivety around the hosting the Olympics and other such mega events (like the Commonwealth Games and the FIFA world cup) that needs to be honestly interrogated.    

Of late there has been the fancy reference to ‘legacy’ that every committee bidding or organizing these events are fixated to that is not only misleading but mythical as well. The justification in almost every bid today is that: i) economically the events would generate and redistribute massive financial capital. ii) Catalyse urban transformation; fast tracking regeneration and renewal of decaying segments of a city’s morphology and addressing issues of urban poverty, social exclusion and inequality. iii) Attract inward investment and tourism critical for promoting growth and creating employment, and  iv) expose a city or a country to valuable international audience strategic for building its image and enhancing its competitiveness.

However, in reality, experience from a majority of previous hosts tells a story extremely divergent from the idealism exuded by the organizers of these events. Cities/countries have incurred huge losses; there is no evidence of inward investment attributable to the image built by the games; large populations have been displaced through evictions for construction or gentrification; and there is little documented impact on the lives of local people. Media accounts of wasteful public spending have tarnished their reputation as vehicles for urban regeneration and portrayed them merely as public relations ventures far removed from the realities of urban problems. Actually the main beneficiaries are seldom the most deserving and needy candidates. They fail to address the underlying structural issues that exacerbate poverty, dereliction and decay in urban landscapes.
  
Let us interrogate these claims honestly and objectively in order to be in a position to judge the Olympics and other mega events for what they truly are:

Massive financial capital OR Massive public investment – value for money
Except for the Los Angeles Olympics of 1984 and Atlanta 1996, not one mega sporting event can claim to have made profits out of the games. The norm has been that the actual costs far outstrip the estimated costs during the bidding process. Revenues generated do not come up at least to the expectations of their organizers. The CWG at Edinburgh in 1986 apparently incurred a £4.3 million deficit; the actual cost of the Manchester Games surged to £670 million and the plan to raise revenues through advertising and tickets flopped; the initial bid for the Melbourne CW Games estimated it would cost $195 million but eventually exploded to over $1.1 billion. By 2010, the Glasgow 2014 budget had increased from £373 million submitted at the time of the bid to £523 million. 

The Montreal Olympics of 1976 earned the name – ‘The Big Owe’ drawing from the huge debt that Quebec accumulated from hosting the games. In fact the $1.5-billion debt from the 1976 Summer Games was paid off in full by Canadian tax payers 3 decades on in 2006. Athens 2004 Olympics cost a record £9.4bn way over original budget. This left Greece with huge debt amounting to about €50,000 for each Greek household to foot. Maintenance of the sites alone cost as much as £500m. The Sydney Olympics 2000 cost about $6billion costing the public at least $1.5bn (about £720m) in deficit. And true to the Olympic fashion, the London Olympics 2012 overrun the initial budget by 101% in real terms to end up at US$14.8 billion by the time of the opening ceremony on 27th July 2012.

Clearly, the economic viability of these events need not be over-debated, truth be told, they have not demonstrated the capacity to generate surplus revenue for the host cities and nations. They have instead burdened the tax payer with extra expenses that do not match up benefits accrued from them. Without robust systems of financial control, accountability and performance management to ensure value for money and delivery on agreed outcomes, they are poised to draw money away from public sector investment that would be better spent on education, healthcare rather than sports facilities.

Reconstruction of urban form or transfer of decay
The IOC argues that as one of the legacy issues, the games facilitate development of new infrastructure to encourage economic regeneration, revitalise, remediate and regenerate deprived inner city areas and make them attractive to business and open up new opportunities for employment.

However, there is a tension between the construction of the image of prosperity and attractiveness and the actively concealed landscapes of urban poverty and deprivation. Neighbourhoods are made-over to create a shiny image for tourism and investment but the underlying structural causes of their decay not addressed. Under the logic of event-oriented development, the visibility of poverty is an eyesore; preparations often involve removing the poor from high-profile areas surrounding event venues without significant attention to long-term solutions to slum problems. There were massive displacement of over 1.5 million Chinese to construct the Birds nest in Beijing for 2008 Olympics; to beautify Seoul for 1988 Olympics, South Korea evicted residents for clearance and development of around 100 sites. In Cape Town, homeless people were moved from the downtown area around the stadium into razor wire encircled encampments outside the city for the 2010 world cup. “They want to make a good impression for the foreigners coming. We are like flies to them.” There was a row with Glaswegians in Dalmarnock over evictions and closure of a market of historical value for constructions for the Glasgow 2014 commonwealth games. The construction of the athletes' village in Stratford (London East-end) broke up a community that had been on the site legally since 1972. In sum the evictions have disrupted community and neighborhood ties, curtailed social capital and diminished locality identities for a shiny image makeover that can only conceal so much from investors and tourist eyes for so long.

Furthermore, the displacements aside, the history of mega events is that they have increased housing prices and cost of living in such neighbourhoods and technically driven out initial householders. "Olympic effect" helped to hike property prices beyond the means of many in Barcelona. According to homeless charity Shelter, across East London landlords evicted tenants to cash in on lucrative Olympics rental demand. Most events have merely transferred unemployment, poverty and deprivation to urban fringes as they bolster city competitiveness; image and physical environment. Moreover, many hosts have ended up with their overall negative aspects unaffected; despite massive expenditure in the costly facilities that remain underutilised and cost more to maintain after the games.

Addressing Social exclusion
Mega events have been touted as drivers for enhancing social inclusion. The argument has been that they would enhance human capital development and community participation – provide volunteering opportunities and apprenticeships, and create new jobs. However, though volunteering programmes can enhance personal development and confidence of those who participate, there is a weak link between volunteering and getting long-term, high quality jobs most needed by such groups. Nature of employment generated has normally been criticized for its poor quality and lack of longevity. To many local populations, major events are often viewed as an imposition from outside. Manchester 2002 did not succeed in establishing an inclusive approach to the decision making process. Community participation was lacking in Delhi 2010 as well; described as a case of misplaced priorities and an attempt at nurturing a fragile sense of national pride. After forced eviction and relocation to unfavourable property – a resident noted: “I was happy about London getting the Olympics, but we haven’t been treated right as a community. They wouldn’t have done it to any other people. No-one’s even offered us a free ticket.”

Image Legacy
Mega events are argued to expose a city/country to international audience with the ability to raise perceptions. Sports fans may enjoy their visit and return after the games, investors and venture capitalists may relocate manufacturing facilities, company headquarters, or start new business in the city based on their experience. Television viewers might decide to visit, seek work, education or to reside in the city based on what’s advertised. They could also inspire and bolster national pride, and unity that inspire confidence in a city/nation. President Nelson Mandela wearing the jersey of Francois Pienaar during the 1995 Rugby World Cup final in South Africa was a powerful  image message to the world that South Africa had emerged from its years of racial oppression and served to unify the country. Ray Nagin, Mayor of New Orleans exclaimed that the return of the NFL in 2000 was an important symbol of recovery from the hurricane Katrina.

However, in principle, a city's external image is generally durable. Mega events combined with an advertising campaign may influence specific aspects of a city's image which in turn may influence the decision to visit. However, a city’s image is normally compartmentalised in the psyche of an individual. A mega sporting event may well leave the overall negative aspects unaffected. Momentary spotlight doesn’t necessarily translate into sustainable growth. There is virtually no evidence (save for the case of Seoul) of post event testing of outcomes that were predicted. The claim that the events attract investment and tourism critical for promoting growth and creating employment is itself not tenable. No examples documented of companies moving operations or setting up businesses based on decisions attributed to the hosting of a mega event. Neither is there sufficient evidence of populations shifting to live in host cities after the hosting of such events.  

Mega events may as well taint the image of a city and negate the regeneration efforts especially when the media coverage is not managed to the advantage of the city/country. The riots across England in summer 2011 very well threatened the dividends of image that London 2012 Olympics organizers hoped to achieve. The ticket-empty seats mishap? Atlanta failed to capitalise on the Olympics publicity; the Central Park bombing, severe heat and humidity drew negative publicity and the press nicknamed the city – “Hotlanta”. Bribery scandal surrounding the 2002 Salt lake winter Olympics, the Terror attacks of Munich and Atlanta, the 1990 riots in Detroit during the NBA finals all served to taint the image of the hosts.


If you ask me: improvement of a city’s image and physical environment will not automatically address the fundamental structural causes of poverty. There is certainly no guarantee that a major sporting event will produce positive social and/or economic benefits for the host and it’s debatable as to exactly who, within the host population, benefits.

Monday, 16 July 2012


A 4-Point Policy Proposal to East Africa on the discovery of oil and gas in the region

This is an excerpt of a blog I wrote for Development Initiatives following up on the round table forum on the discovery of oil and gas in East Africa's and what it means for the region's poor held at the Hilton, Nairobi on Tuesday 3rd July 2012. This was a multi-stakeholder forum that converged key policy makers from government, civil society, the media, academia and other citizen representatives in Kenya. The Panel comprised: Tech Blogger, Robert Alai–Techmtaa; Maragua MP and Chair House Committee on Budget, Hon Elias Mbau MP–Kenya Parliament; Director Economic Affairs, Henry Rotich, Ministry of Finance–Kenya; Charles Abugre–UNDP; Kwame Owino, CEO- Institute of Economic Affairs – Kenyaand Social Justice Activist Okiah Okoiti Omtatah. Moderated by Charles Onyango-Obbo –Executive Editor for Africa and Digital Media Division, NMG



"If we are walking on gold, then why are we so poor” – sentiments of a Ghanaian Elder

Development Initiatives’ Africa hub hosted its first Africacounts round table forum on 3 July 2012. The purpose of the forum was to stimulate honest and constructive dialogue about the potential role natural resource revenues can play in addressing poverty, deprivation and inequality in the East African region. The outcome was the production of evidenced-based and inclusive policy messages to influence the use of East Africa’s newfound natural resource wealth for eradicating extreme and chronic poverty. It was a multi-stakeholder forum that converged key policy makers from government, civil society, the media, academia and other citizen representatives in Kenya. The forum situated the discovery of natural resources such as oil in Kenya and Uganda and natural gas in Tanzania within a poverty context, highlighting the potential impact that these resources and revenues could have on development in the region. Participants discussed the history of natural resource extraction on the continent and the prospects for East Africa.

Four key issues emerged from the discussions to inform policy decisions in the region:

 I: Develop robust fiscal policies to facilitate the effective management of emerging natural resources in order to optimise the opportunities that they could bring.

“The answer to effective utilization of East Africa’s natural resource find to address poverty and the pressing developmental challenges lies in treating the discovery of oil and gas as a public finance management issue.”
Henry Rotich, Ministry of Finance, Kenya

There needs to be reform within budget structures to allow flexibility in revenue allocation and in order to prioritise key development issues within pro-poor sectors. Suggested ways forward:
· expand the oil footprint in the economy instead of focusing on oil revenues as the driver of growth and for delivering public goods
· design and execute effective tax regimes that maximise on revenues from investors but also maintain a reasonable tax package to enhance the citizen stake in governance
· challenge the state’s role in the management of emerging resources and develop alternative modalities for managing and sharing the proceeds from natural resource discoveries
· increase citizens’ stake in oil production through the institutionalisation of mechanisms for key stakeholders, such as citizens and the government, to invest in the whole value chain in oil production.
"Why must the state dominate the management of emerging natural resources? Could we think outside the box?”
Kwame Owino, CEO, Institute of Economic Affairs

 II: Open information and increase civil knowledge. East African countries should commit to putting information about emerging natural resources into the public domain so that processes and procedures are more transparent. Greater effort needs to be made to enhance e-governance, develop open data initiatives and formulate right-to-information legislation.

“Put information about the actual oil find, terms entered into, agreements with multinationals and modalities for monitoring flow of revenue to the public… [...] Oil needs very careful control, open consensus with the public. [...] It is cash, a key foreign policy commodity.”
Charles Abugre, UNDP

III: Develop and maintain laws, effective institutions and policies capable of managing resources, regulating exploitation and ensuring maximum benefit for citizens. The function of a legislative and institutional framework should be to regulate revenue-sharing formulae, tax regimes, policy and legislative space for civil society organisations (CSOs) and citizens’ representatives. Without such regulation, profits from natural resource discovery can often lead to poor governance and corruption.

“Petro-dictatorship: Oil and gas find might herald an era of strong dictatorship in East Africa…”
Kwame Owino, CEO, Institute of Economic Affairs

IV: Increase citizen engagement in CSO and media space. There has been significant expansion in public engagement and participation in recent years. This emerging space provides an opportunity for CSOs and the media (especially new media) to play a critical role as citizen representatives to ensure that policy makers prioritise their needs when overseeing the management of East Africa’s natural resource wealth.

“Civil society, social justice activists and the media (including social media) shouldn’t wait for government to pass laws then complain.”
Robert Alai, Blogger Techmtaa, Kenya

The media and CSOs need to ensure that governments are held to account and are transparent about natural resource revenues. They must be proactive in influencing government action such as challenging malpractice, pushing through policy suggestions, proposing new or revised legislation in order to maximise the benefits of natural resources in addressing chronic poverty.

“We have been unable to effectively utilise what we have: that’s why we are poor.”
Okoiti Okiah Omtatah, Social Justice Activist



Follow this link for detailed information about the Africacouts round table forum

Thursday, 12 April 2012

Where art thou oh African Philanthropist?

‘In everything I did, I showed you that by this kind of hard work we must help the weak, remembering the words the Lord Jesus himself said: It is more blessed to give than to receive’ (Acts 20:35 NIV)


Last Night as I skimmed through the OECD Credit Reporting System (CRS), I noticed that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation actually features on the dataset as a key donor reporting well over $2.9 billion worth of foreign aid to developing nations and $0.75 billion worth of commitments to Sub-Sahara Africa between 2009 and 2010. Well it is common knowledge that private entities and foundations financed by the world’s rich and renowned philanthropists today contribute a significant proportion of development assistance channelled to countries commonly referred to in aid parlance as the Highly Indebted Poor Countries. The list doesn’t end with the Gates foundation, a lot more other generous rich men and women have extended their generosity and committed significant proportions of their wealth to supporting organizations and initiatives that work to reduce human suffering, restore human dignity, alleviate and mitigate the effects of poverty.


But that’s not the reason I woke up early this morning to do this post: certainly not. I came across this list of the richest men and women of the African continent published by the Forbes magazine and I was honestly flabbergasted! Men, don’t we have rich people down here! I mean men and women who have earned their wealth out of legitimate mercantile ventures (I elect to down play the plethora of others, probably way richer than the ones on Forbes, whose wealth is of dubious cradles). I mean the likes of Aliko Dangote ($11.2 billion), Nigeria; Mohamed Al Amoudi ($12.5 billion), Ethiopia/Saudi; Mike Adenuga ($4.3 billion), Nigeria; Nassef and Naquib Sawiri (over $8.2 billion), Egypt; Patrice Motsepe ($2.7 billion), South Africa Miloud Chaabi ($2.9 billion), Morocco and so on. These guys are billionaires in their own right, making it in this continent of perceived squalor, ineptitude and misery.

The question that lurked in my mind as I read through this list was why Africa’s richest have failed the philanthropy test? Why haven’t these honourable men of the African soil found it prudent and befitting to share a small steady proportion of this share of the African cake with the desperate folks engulfed in poverty and deprivation in Sub Sahara? How comes other men and women elsewhere have felt the pinch, the pain and suffering of fellow Africans a lot more than we do us African Moguls, billionaires? How comes it doesn’t disturb you honourable vanguards of my decent that people miles away from the villages of Pampaida, N/Nigera; Malehice, Mozambique; Marsabit, Kenya; Mai Chaka, Ethiopia; Candele, Angola, come all the way to feed our starving folks, treat our sickling children, clothe our women and shelter our families. How shameful?

Do a small quick math – take Aliko Dangote for example, ranked 76th richest being on earth, with an empire worth over $11 billion USD in 2011. This is four times the total GDP of the republic of Burundi, 30% that of Kenya, twice Nigeria’s 2011 federal budget and 55 times Nigeria’s health sector budget in the same year. Dangote’s pre-tax turnover in 2010 was well over $100 million dollars: just slightly about 8% of this profit margin is equivalent to the $0.8 billion required for the Nigeria Federal government to beat the target of committing at least 15% of total government revenue for health sector spending set in Abuja by Africa heads of states in 2000. Likewise Mohamed Al Amoudi is ranked 63rd wealthiest man (also richest black man). His business empire worth $12.5 billion in 2011 was 15% total GDP of the five East African countries and equivalent to South Sudan’s average GDP between 2008 and 2010.  
I am by no means claiming even vaguely that there haven’t been philanthropic gestures from noble individuals around Africa; NO. In fact there have been anecdotes of evidence showing significant contributions (albeit irregular, unpredictable and devoid of focus) to health, education and cultural sectors, most visibly sport. Dangote through the Dangote Foundation has reportedly supported education and health service delivery systems and provided humanitarian assistance to victims of natural disasters and post-election and religious crises in Nigeria, Al Amoudi likewise has supported breast cancer research and HIV/AIDS interventions, notably the International Conference on AIDS and STIs (ICASA). However, I am posing these questions because I thought well to do Africans could logically identify a lot more with the poverty in Africa than anyone else; and I thought as well that they could be a lot more challenged and incentivised to give than those from other continents. I believe what is forthcoming from Africa’s tycoons is far too little considering the proportion of Africa’s resources that sustains their wealth. And whenever they give, that which is forthcoming has invariably been unpredictable, not properly organised and never harmonised with state structures and systems that factor in aid in country resource baskets and expenditures.  

Free market privileges notwithstanding, I think it has reached the point where the same manner of activism and a commensurate measure of pressure that has been put on rich countries and capitalists to support poverty and developmental initiatives needs to assume the direction of Africa’s home grown tycoons. Their wealth reflects continued consumption of significant chunks of Africa’s resources and they must thus do the honourable thing ... start GIVING: giving a little more, transparently and regularly. Motsepe’s mines are obviously depleting a considerable amount of South Africa’s mineral deposits; Dangote’s cement empire is definitely exhausting West Africa’s rich limestone fields, Al Amoudi’s oil ventures sure have their share of destruction on Africa’s environment and natural resources, Adenuga’s telecom business has so far cashed in on West Africa’s purchasing population and Uhuru Kenyatta is of course holding on to humongous tracks of land that multitudes of Kenyans could do with.  If anything, isn’t that what legacy is all about, playing a part in making the world a better place for all of us.  

The big names in global philanthropy, the likes of J.D Rockefeller Jnr, Bill Gates, George Soros and other consistent foundations that continue to deliver funding for development projects in Africa like the Levi Strauss, Hewllet, Ford foundations have well structured and organized modalities for delivering portions of their wealth as development assistance. This is well aligned with state structures and could be streamlined to compliment and supplement government budgets and developmental objectives. That is obviously lacking in Africa; the few who have attempted to institutionalise their giving are unpredictable, irregular and lack the transparency that is requisite for aid effectiveness. Most of the resource flows from Africa’s moguls have been expended in financing sport and culture related ventures and pursuing political expediency.  Al Amoudi for example has handsomely sponsored the Council for East and Central Africa Football Associations (CECAFA), Dangote hugely funding former Nigerian president Olusegun Obasanjo’s political campaigns as well as incumbent Goodluck Jonathan who even awarded him one of Nigeria’s highest ranks of nobility; Mike Adenuga’s Glocom has equally funded music competitions across West Africa.  Otherwise, a lot of news about these billionaires is normally about their luxurious indulgences that ridicule the continent. The $45 million bombardier XRS private jet that Dangote got himself on his 53rd birthday in 2011 for example was equivalent to 80% of all aid disbursements for education sector spending in South Sudan in the same year.

My message to the Forbes 10 African Billionaires to watch - messrs:  Manu Chandaria (Kenya), Phuthuma Nhleko (South Africa), Naushad Merali (Kenya), Tokyo Sexwale (South Africa), Harold Pupkewitz (Namibia), Said Salim Bakhresa (Tanzania), Gilbert Chagoury (Nigeria), Antonio Oladeinde Fernandez (Nigeria), Kase Lawal (Nigeria) and Isabel Dos Santos (Angola) - when your pockets eventually cross the billionaire mark, remember that as much as the liberal market economy today rewards and privileges hard working individuals with huge perks (in the form of profits and comfort) ... it doesn’t preclude and relieve the rest of us African folk from our share of the continents wealth. Find it within you as a matter of obligation and morality to share the spoil. And while you are at it, care to be more predictable and transparent. Foreign philanthropy has succeed somewhat and so must African philanthropy.

IN ANY CASE EVEN GOD DEMANDS OF US TO BE KIND