Saturday, 2 March 2013



PLEASE ASK KENYANS TO GET OUT AND VOTE ON Monday March 4th 2013

Hi
My name is Kenneth Okwaroh Ochieng. Also Known As Okwaroh Ja’Paprombe on face book. I blog at Okwarohztake. I have a thousand plus friends on facebook, I follow many noble and interesting people on twitter and they follow me as well. I have over 300 connections on linked in, and have close to a thousand people in my circles on Google plus. I have travelled the world and met awesome people, made friends, classmates, workmates ...

Folks am afraid but I have to do this. It is the least I can do to my country right now. My country Kenya is at cross roads. We are less than 24 hours into an extremely important general election. An election that demands of us to deal with a problematic past and juggle the promises and challenges that the future holds. It boils down to folks getting out as many a possible to VOTE. To vote enough to enable us distinguish a clear winner. Going by opinion polls that have run in the past 3 months – it is a neck-to-neck race pitting two arch rivals with strong personal and emotive opposing opinions that is cannon fodder for violence and ethnic animosity.  Our people are reeling from the aftermath of the 2007 general election when unfortunate events led to peace-loving citizens taking arms against one another, killing over 1000 innocent people, displacing over half a million from their homes, destroying property worth trillions and crippling an economy that was in the path towards double digit growth.

I am writing to ask you that PLEASE, if you know a Kenyan, if you have any one of them in your networks (facebook, twitter, linkedin, Google+, foursquare, badoo, etc) - PLEASE ask them to get out on Monday 4th March and VOTE. If they are out there in the Diaspora, kindly ask them to spread this message to their constituencies.


Africa must indeed live up to its true potential. It begins with having civilised political transitions. We need Kenyans to get out and VOTE because if they don’t, we are headed into a RUN-OFF that is bound to be too costly in terms of resources and in terms of undermining the progress we have made in the difficult past 5 years reforming our institutions, reengineering our nationhood and building a responsive 21st century state.

We have already expended way above our means as a nation in real investment towards reforming the electoral process, the judiciary and internal security regime. The campaigns alone have been perversely expensive and have had significant impact on the economy already.

A run-off puts Kenya in a one month limbo when everything and anything could happen. It is appreciably an uneasy calm and we are doing our best to preach peace - but the run-off will sure ignite emotions, tension and will polarise Kenya in unprecedented measures.

As a nation we have brokered peace around the world -  in South Sudan, spearheaded the renaissance of Somalia and are a beacon of regional stability, political tranquillity and economic prosperity in the East African region. Kenya calls on you to at least return a favour at this moment of need. 

If you love Kenya - 1) Our beautiful sceneries – the great Mount Kenya, our cosy beaches in Mombasa, Lamu and Malindi; 2) Our rich heritage – the lion daring Maasai; 3) Our beautiful city in the Sun Nairobi where life never stops; 4) Our thrilller rugby 7s team, 5) our resillient athletes. If you love Peace, If you want prosperity and stability in East Africa, Africa and the world. 

PLEASE ASK KENYANS TO GET OUT AND VOTE ON Monday March 4th 2013.

Thank you. Yours truly
Okwaroh Ja’ paprombe

And please if you do not like my message, be the gentleman or lady and just overlook it

Thursday, 28 February 2013

Wednesday, 16 January 2013

The five breeds Kenyans must avoid in tommorows nominations and the March 2013 ballot 

["Having eyes, see ye not? and having ears, hear ye not? and do ye not remember?"(Mark 8:18). ... This people's heart is waxed gross, and their ears are dull of hearing, and their eyes they have closed; lest at any time they should see with their eyes and hear with their ears, and should understand with their heart...]
Kenya is positioning herself for a circus in the waiting; on Thursday 17th January, 2013 dominant parties nominate their favourites to run for elective positions in the March 3rd 2013 general elections. I can’t wait as well, the stakes have are high, and a string of fallouts is looming amongst party losers. Anyway, I have been accused many times before on this blog of being overly pessimistic, paranoid, suspicious and reactionary. I hope this sits well with the sceptics: this is my 20 pence counsel to Kenyans as they go to the nominations and into the epic March 2013 ballot.


If there is any miracle that ever happened to Kenya, it must be the promulgation of the new constitution on August 27th 2010. The perks are already too evident and the prospects appetising. For me I seek to warn Kenyans, to live up to their true selves, not to squander this one. Kenyans, when you go to the ballot forget all else and pay utmost attention to the GOVERNOR. There lies the paradise that new katiba promises the ordinary Kenyan. There lies what symbolises the break from the old order.

What governors do:
The governor has a greater effect on the daily lives of ordinary citizens than the president, the senator, or Member of Parliament ever would. Governors across the globe lead county governments or states with executive and legislative authority. They set policy (have influence on national policy decisions as well), recommend/enact legislations, prepare and administer budgets and determine how revenues are spent at the county/state level. They regulate business and are generally responsible for the delivery of crucial goods and services like health and safety, transport and planning that profoundly affect the overall well being of their citizens. They are mandated and accountable to the public on the promotion of economic development, wealth creation, social development, environmental management, and cultural preservation. They are directly responsible for policing the performance of the county/state. 

"... What do businesses need to grow and flourish and take on new people? They need their employees to be able to afford to live within a reasonable commuting distance from their place of work. A job creating economy [therefore] needs good HOUSING and good TRANSPORT" (London mayor - Boris Johnson).

What your governor must do:
However away from the theories of the roles and responsibilities of the governor; the overarching duty of the typical successful governor must be wealth creation and equitable redistribution of public resources. It boils down to attracting investment, promoting new businesses and creating jobs. Clearly, out of the fear of losing power the political establishment in Kenya already skewed the system to favour the central government and denied the counties substantial resource allocation to actualise the aspirations of citizens. As it is less than 25% of total government revenue will reach the devolved structures to be engaged in direct delivery of public goods. The successful governor must thus be the one:

·  That will generate surplus resources; look beyond government, to marshal inward investment (both foreign and domestic), make the environment (in terms of energy, infrastructure, security and housing) suitable for new business to set up and thrive and with the sanity to avoid destroying jobs.
·    With the aptitude to ring fence resources for development while still maintaining prudent public finance management policies and ideals.
·      That will muster the skill and capacity to exploit the existing resources to the advantage of the county while guaranteeing their sustainability.
·   Who will enhance the competitiveness of the county’s urban areas, step up place marketing and attract new populations to do business and to increase the market.
·        With the instinct, connections and skill to organize indabas and investment fairs to sell the county as the ultimate destinations for business, tourism, education and the many other unique attributes it might posses.

While that must sound as the typical economic approach to management of the county, it must happen on the background of a political framework with ideals that most often run parallel and invariably antagonistic to the business model. As provided for in Article 176 –
‘There shall be a county government for each county consisting of a county assembly [the legislative arm] and a county executive’. What this means then is that the governor must be the individual with the ability to tactfully marry the politics and the economics of the county. Surely, that demands a mix of a technocrat with experience and skill in public administration, management, and governance; business acumen; a knack of politics, and wide connections borne out of outward linkages abroad as well as in other counties domestically.

If that doesn’t help you decide on the most suitable. Here is a list of the characters you must avoid like plague. Experience has taught us that these breeds of persons are capable and indeed will squander the fortunes of a county no matter how endowed. Do not elect/nominate:

I - The tattered ex-MP
This is the typical hangovered Member of Parliament who has squandered five years of exclusive authority, resources and political will now only looking to save a dying political life, struggling to keep relevant in Kenya’s hyper-dynamic political-economic trajectory. Let his/her record speak for itself, the mediocrity he/she has served you over the past five years will sure not metamorphosise overnight into the brilliant entity that the onerous county leadership demands. Do not be fooled, the typical one just won’t however sweet he/she talks.


II – The loud mouth devious know it all attorney
No offence to the legal profession. But with all due respect, it is the crop of lawyers that have hijacked the Kenyan legislative system that bare the greatest responsibility for the dark times this country has endured. If they have not cleverly mutilated every little bit of well thought legislations, they have arrogantly manipulated the legal system to award themselves outrageous undeserving perks. They have taken over parliament and treated us to perennial side shows and confounding legal jargon that effectively distracted us from the serious issues that affect the prosperity of our nation. And most shameful is the way they have presided over the polarisation of our once peaceful united nation. Woe unto to you positioning yourself to rebrand another loser like that into a governor.

III – The tired retired civil servant
There are those who have diligently served Kenya, those who deserve and must be accorded the respect they have so earned. In whatever state department they have worked, they have done their duty to this nation. However, it is my opinion that they must do the honourable thing: let the country move on and enjoy the leadership of other equally capable, young and apt citizens. While some of them have been very dynamic and could manage the demands of the current system, there is also the lot (the larger constituency) that has clearly been overtaken by events, the ones only keen on keeping themselves busy, or gratifying the lost authority/power that came with higher echelon civil service jobs.
  
IV – The ass-licking party leadership darling
This is personal and I must let you know that these are so far the greatest enemies of our democracy and the thieves of our destiny and prosperity. These are folks who boot lick, the ‘yes men’ of the Kenyan political partydom. They are cannon fodder for the ‘big man’, they heckle when needed, provide quorum when it is due. They are political sycophants that will do anything to satisfy their patron because that’s the price they pay for political favours yonder! These characters will scare you with direct nominations, party assurances and support from party bigwigs. History has it they most often get their way; they end up in leadership out of deceit and political arm twisting of the electorate. Open your eyes, these folks have no agenda for their constituents but you will be told by party bigwigs that they have been loyal, provided funding, championed the course blah blah ...  


V – The Ill-schooled ‘man of the people’          
He/she is charismatic, commands a great following, is down to earth and probably has a feel and great understanding of the needs and aspirations of their constituents. The trouble with some of them is their capacity (intellectually and/or practically). If they are not utterly out of touch with logic and commonsense, their schooling is deficient and invariably hamstrings their ability to think constructively and layout coherent plausible plans that can be appreciated by others (development partners, investors or academia). If I were you, their popularity notwithstanding, I would shy away from this breed as well.  

“He that hath ears to hear, let him hear” - Matthew 11:15

Saturday, 5 January 2013


'EAC-mania' Obsession and haste towards a monetary/political union. Sentiments of a sceptic

When cautioning against the haste to stardom, former British PM Tony Blair once said that: “ ... history [...] is littered with [...] those who were supposed to be rising stars and ended up being shooting stars"
I had a brief stint with the Secretary General of the East African Community – Dr Richard Sezibera on twitter a few days ago. Well it began as a polite fair response to what I thought was an overly optimistic and misleading tweet, but it degenerated into a back and forth that I honestly didn’t expect. Dr. Sezibera (rightfully) sought to ‘sex-up’ the morale of his constituency of ‘EAC-maniacs’ to accelerate the integration process: the commitments and milestones towards a monetary union and political federation. My response was a patriotic constructive piece of criticism that I hoped could jog the good Doctor’s mind. However what ensued was a PR flair of defence and apologetics some of which bordered sheer defeatism devoid of substance and reason; obviously away from the object of my tweet. Dr. Sezibera went on to question my allegiance to the ‘East African nation’, beating the EAC drum a tad bit too loud and irking my already uncomfortable psyche and unsettled opinion about the ongoing EAC integration process that he presides over.

Nonetheless as a student of multilateralism and global governance, I elected to free myself of the yokes of semantics and sentimentalism on social media and today I bare a few realities about the East African Integration project that could benefit others willing to listen.

Foremost, I am in principle against the shuttling of East Africans into a monetary union and an even more laughable political federation that they are largely ignorant about and have not given their consent to. However, I favour the galvanization of the Common Market Protocol and the Customs Union to promote more trade, greater movement of goods, persons and services across the region which of course can thrive without the sharing of a singular currency or existing within a common political boundary.


Dr Ssezibera and Co. have failed to lobby the ‘EAC-sceptics’ in the region (especially elements in Tanzania) that continue to frustrate the implementation of the Common Market Protocol, yet they are wetting their appetites for a monetary and political union. Indeed folly is superficial to many yet not obvious as well to many alike. I mean you cannot muster the muscle and apparatus to reign in states to implement a customs union yet you yap so invariably about accelerating towards a more onerous ‘United States of East Africa’.

Like a friend of mine brazenly puts it: ‘There are a few people; a few tattered despots here in East Africa threatened by the expanding democratic space in their states who sleep and dream of controlling the economic and political trajectories of the region without legitimate mandate.’ The sound of ‘President of the East African Community’ must be music to their ears. These are the folks hell bent on creating a union of East African States without substance, will or plan for the regions prosperity but to gratify their perverse appetites for political power and economic imperialism. The problem I have with folks in Africa is the obsession with ‘ape-manship’. People are too fond of copying and pasting things they stumble upon elsewhere across the globe without paying sufficient attention to the contextualities (if there is a word like that) of sometimes very noble initiatives – the East African Community is  classic example.

There are pertinent issues regarding the manner in which the integration process is being handled that are not right yet are being effectively swept under the carpet by the secretariat and the project’s other apologisers that I will not falter to point out:

I – Suspicion and Mistrust amongst partner states
It is suspicion and mistrust that indeed hamstrung and sent the defunct EAC to its grave. Those ills are alive today, and maybe even more pronounced by the recent oil and natural gas finds in Kenya Uganda and Tanzania. If it is not Tanzanians perennially scared of the ultra-capitalistic demeanour of Kenyan entrepreneurs and investors, it is the worry of political instability and lack of a sufficient threshold of commonality in political ideals (may be there isn’t any distinctive political ideology anyway). If it is not the fear of marginalised constituencies in smaller partner states concerned about their likely domination in the EAC it is the more financially apt states whining about the likelihood of partner states like Rwanda and Uganda with huge domestic debt portfolios transmitting fiscal trouble.

Moreover financial commitment to the secretariat so far has been scanty signifying an apparent reluctance towards deeper integration beyond the Customs Union. The debates on the modalities for contribution – whether to fund the framework equally among partner states or to contribute proportionately based on the size of individual economies - are increasingly rocking the spirit of the union. There is also the lot that is cautious about the legal requirement that states transfer monetary sovereignty to the union that carries with it the risks of exposing them to external shocks transposed by weak financial systems in other partner states.

The suspicions range from socio-cultural, to economic, political and legal uncomfortabilties that the secretariat itself already commissioned a study and complied a report with a plethora of fears expressed by citizens yet so little has been done to address them. Nonetheless in the words of Dr. Ssezibera ‘we must run where others are walking’ towards the ultimate – the monetary and political union.


 II – Deficits of democracy and national authority
Nigel Farage, Leader of UK Independence Party (UKIP) perpetually roars the ills of hurling Britain into the EU in the European parliament and his fears are genuine. Fears that East Africans are entitled to learn. He argues that with multilateralism comes the cessation of natural authority; certain sovereignties are obviated and critical autonomies curtailed. Yet the multilateral frameworks so created are run by entities recruited outside the confines of conventional democratic processes like universal suffrage. They are normally a construction of handpicked technocrats with no public mandate whatsoever who wield dangerous perverse authority, antagonistic and disobedient of the civil liberties and aspirations of ordinary citizens. Such frameworks and their managers are seldom accountable to citizens.

And true to his word: look at the two institutions that the EAC secretariat has so far successfully presided over their building: the East Africa Legislative Assembly and the East Africa Court of Justice.  At what point in the process did any East African state hold a referendum or carry out meaningful public consultation to seek the opinion of citizens or their representatives on the conduct of these institutions? The East Africa Legislative Assembly is the classic exemplification of multilateral dictatorship and cronyism (I can speak authoritatively for Kenya). Political parties handpicked losers (political rejects who had lost elections elsewhere) based on their allegiance and patron client relationships who were then seconded by a hangovered parliament to the regional assembly. These are the same folks that will soon be handing down legislations (and policy material) to poor ignorant East African citizens who barely know them and their credentials.  

“If you rob people of their identity, if you rob them of their demoracy; all that they are left with is nationalism and violence. I can only hope that the Europroject is destroyed by the markets before that happens” ~ Nigel Farage (UKIP leader)

Look yonder: Greece is now being governed by a troika, a bunch of fellows, technocrats who fly into Athens and preside over the auctioning of the destiny of a people who were once the inventers of modern democracy. Helpless Greeks watch as they are lectured by foreigners on the character of government to have, and as the European Central Bank arrogantly thrashes down their throats fiscal policies that are obviously out of touch with their plight and aspirations. Yet they are bungled, unable to cope with the outrageous austerity prescriptions handed down by Eurozone big-boys and scared of the consequences of exiting the Eurozone in order to autonomously operate a distinct currency and reengineer the political economy of their country.
That is another awkward reality that East Africans might find themselves in someday (god forbid) yet it is effectively concealed from the common mwanainchi.

III – Eminent inequalities and lack of sufficient commonality in key integration ingredients
East African states exist within very divergent democratic and governance trajectories. To mean that there those that have made considerable progress towards good governance, constitutionalism, rule of law, democratic space and there are those who still have an appreciably long way to go. The duty of marrying these polities and conglomerating their unequal trajectories demands enormous capacity, political will and obligation that have been undoubtedly deficient and the situation doesn’t look like changing in the near future.
Then there is the thorny issue of access to natural resources, some that are spatially concentrated in some states like the unresolved issue of lake Victoria. Clearly there are marked inequalities in endowment with natural resources which will hugely determine the economic and political muscle of different partner states and tip the balance of power in the coveted union.

These are but snippets of the realities that confront the ambitious integration process that should keep the secretariat busy; working on how to address within the framework of the Customs Union even before thinking of greater unions. The need to build social cohesion across the region; to manage power relations among partner states; enhance legitimacy/credibility of the process itself through greater and more meaningful citizen engagement; and to forestall an effective conflict management mechanism cannot be overemphasised. If the intentions of the EAC are as noble and genuine as they should obviously be, then the project deserves a threshold of patience, tact and reason which the secretariat must accord it. Like in my tweet I reiterate that ‘we’ must be ware not to manufacture another Euro-like mishap in East Africa.   ‘We must interrogate the events that led to the demise of the defunct EAC, learn from the EU, SADC, ASEAN, NAFTA. Unfortunately when i possed this suggestion Dr Sezibera's response was that we must not focus out there because EAC is awesome
“@rsezibera: @Okwaroh why don't we focus on eac? I think we are better than Europe”

Monday, 3 December 2012


When poverty reduction competes with state building: 

The case of South Sudan

The world’s youngest nation, South Sudan, has now had over a year of political economic autonomy, following a break away from Sudan in July 2011. Independence was preceded by the period after the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement in 2005, during which it operated as a semi-autonomous government. South Sudan has since made significant progress in restoration of peace, political transition, establishment of governance structures towards building a stable state. There have also been improvements in the socio-economic wellbeing of the people of South Sudan.

However, this has not been without challenges some of which could negate the progress already made. Preliminary analysis on public expenditure and resource flows reveals critical resource management challenges that could have far reaching implications on fiscal sustainability, public accountability and the economic well being of the country’s poor.

Despite significant data limitations and methodological constraints, Kenneth Okwaroh analysed the flow of domestic revenues and Official Development Assistance (ODA) in South Sudan.  He used budget estimates for the period between 2006 and 2011 as a proxy to analyse the intentions, motivations and the character of resource allocation in the country with a specific focus on resource allocations for poverty reduction. The analysis revealed the following:

Acute dependance on oil revenues 
I – The Government of South Sudan (GoSS) acutely depends on oil revenues for its income. Between 2006 and 2011, oil revenues contributed over 98% of state income. This poses a risk to fiscal sustainability especially because the country’s oil production is projected to decrease by 10% by 2019, and by 50% by 2029 if no new reserves are discovered. This lack of diversity in the economy, together with increasing dependence on imports, increases the country’s vulnerability to fiscal turmoil in the face of external shocks. A classic example is the decision to shut down oil production in response to the dispute with Khartoum that lead to unprecedented inflation rates (80% in May 2012) and profoundly stifled growth. Besides undermining sound -economic management such dependence on oil revenue also impedes effective taxation with significant implications for governance and accountability.

Competing resource demands - Poverty missing out
II – Since the signing of the CPA in 2005, the country has experienced considerable growth in state revenues and ODA flows. However this has not been translated into significant progress in human development, poverty reduction and economic growth. Compared to other states in the East African region, South Sudan has the lowest life expectancy at birth (42 years), lowest adult literacy levels (27%), highest maternal mortality rate (2,054 per 100,000 live births) and one of the highest poverty headcounts (51%). Given these high poverty and welfare indicators, and the direction of government expenditure, it is deducible that, key priority areas for budget allocation are not efficiently and effectively aligned poverty reduction outcomes.

III – South Sudan could be struggling with mechanisms for balancing resource demands for state building with the urgent need to address poverty and human development. Despite government revenues and expenditure steadily expanding, pro-poor sectors such as agriculture, health and education, have been considerably under-funded. For example while state revenues expanded by 17.2% between 2008 and 2012, total expenditure on agriculture, education and health as a proportion of total spending grew by only 11.7%. These three sectors, which were identified as expenditure priorities, collectively received 12.5% of total average spending, compared with security, which received 28.2%. Conversely, public administration and justice, law and order, which were not considered priority sectors, reported higher outturns (11.5% and 11.4% respectively). Moreover expenditure in all three sectors fell short of international standards and targets set by peer states.

Prioritization far from actual spending
IV – There are significant gaps in the alignment of resources with identified expenditure priorities. Both budget allocations and donor commitments are not adequately synchronised with these priorities. For example, the education and health sectors, which the GoSS outlined as priority expenditure areas, received lower proportions of total spending (6.9% and 4.2% respectively) than public administration (11.5%) and rule of law (11.4%), which were not identified as priority sectors.
Okwaroh argues that the findings depict a largely unstable macro-economic environment that least guarantees fiscal sustainability, steady public revenues and predictable public spending. There is compelling evidence that abundant oil revenues in South Sudan coupled with aid could be impinging on effective domestic tax collection. With a small underdeveloped and less diversified formal economy, low capacity government institutions and inefficient tax collection, it risks becoming an import-dependent country afflicted with the ’resource curse’.  Fluctuating GDP growth and instability in the oil industry add to the fragility of a conflict-ridden state, faced with multiple resource demands for reconstruction, state building and poverty reduction. South Sudan must therefore streamline its management of oil and explore alternative, non-oil resource streams – such as agriculture – to ensure fiscal sustainability. It must institute mechanisms to ensure effective balancing of resource demands for state building with funding for poverty response. 

You can find the full report here:  and the data and analyses here: 

Thursday, 18 October 2012


What shall we eat? - Return Smart Sweet Sorghum!


Yesterday I attended a round table on food security with the theme – ‘What shall we eat?’ This was facilitated by the East African on the sides of the launch of Kenya’s 3rd Agriculture Sector Development strategy graced by very important people – Government ministers and big private sector names. Folks went on and on with fancy stuff about eradicating subsistence agriculture and replacing it with Agribusiness to address food deficits in the country. I had a million questions to ask – poor thing the moderator could not spot my short self. So on my way back home, pretty distraught, stuck in Nairobi traffic I wondered why these guys were so out of touch with reality. However one thought kept bugging me. It was the thought of this crop that supplies food, fodder and fiber;  thrives in erratic climatic conditions, has the capacity to provide steady income to poor rural subsistence farmers, and can be harnessed to produce commercial alcohol and safe bio-fuels. I pictured this era of droughts, famines, unemployment, perennial food insecurity and saw policy makers racing to grab this crop. I saw ordinary poor people staring at the spectre of death from hunger actively investing in this crop even without government intervention, just for the sheer theoretical sense that it made. Yet this was just but a figment of fiction in my imagination. In reality this crop is SORGHUM.  Despite overwhelming evidence, it has not seen commensurate investment in its production, consumption and commercial utilization as compared to other peer cereal crops. So today I decided to tell a story - a SORGHUM story!

Anthropological evidence traces sorghum back to 8000BC Africa around western Ethiopia and Chad. It later spread to India, the Middle East and further to the Far East by around 400AD and only arrived in America (today the largest producer) in 1800s. Sorghum was then widely cultivated and consumed as a staple food; utilized in brewing beer, making bread and porridge. Domestically, it was used as fuel, thatch, fencing, housing construction and largely as fodder. Sorghum was a wonder crop; a self repellent to predatory birds, with high nutritional value and high net energy balance. It was a critical diet accessible and known to poor subsistence farmers in semi arid tropics for its resilience and ability to survive erratic weather conditions - (Sorghum matures in only 4 months and requiring just about 4000m3 per hectare - compared to corn that requires 8000m3).  
   

The corn-ish take over:
Well that was until the 1500AD ‘Colombian exchange’ as described by historian Alfred Crosby in reference to the epic importation of corn into Africa facilitated by the transatlantic trade. That exchange would mark the beginning of a massive cereal takeover. No one would have imagined at that point in time that corn would come to colonize the African farm, supplant historical African food grains (like sorghum and millet) and practically hold the African farmer and consumer hostage as the staple (not to do without food). It is however the dawn of commercialized production of corn that dealt the greatest blow to sorghum; suddenly the production and consumption of sorghum products that dated back many centuries stopped, beer brewed from sorghum was replaced with corn, and so was the case with porridge and bread. The reasoning then was that maize was a superior crop both nutritionally and commercially.  Today 16 out of the 23 countries in the world with the highest percentage consumption of maize are African. In Southern Africa, over 50% of total calorific consumption is drawn from corn. Besides colonizing the African plate, maize did colonize the African mind as well. In Malawi, corn is referred to as ‘Chimango cha makola’ meaning maize of the ancestors. Corn has become so entrenched and subdued other cereals to the extent that native Malawians thought it was actually a native crop passed on by their ancestors. 

Sorghum was downgraded mainly based on its palatability (the tannin in sorghum produces a less preferred bitter taste). Attitudes changed so much so that households that had for long cultivated and consumed sorghum turned to corn. Those that continued to cultivate sorghum were stigmatized and considered poor. In rural Africa, a social stratification emerged that categorized those that consumed only maize as “well to do” (at the highest level of society), those that mixed maize and sorghum flour as “middle class” and those who consumed pure sorghum or millet as “poor” households. This further entrenched the stigma against sorghum and created a production disincentive. Today sorghum occupies less than 25% of arable land across Africa, and globally it is number five among the largest cereal crops after wheat, rice, maize and barley.

Climate Change:
And then came climate change. This brought with it new realities in the battle between corn and other traditional African cereals. Alas, the reliable rainfall that corn so heavily depended on is no longer predictable. Moreover soil productivity has declined as a result of over production, poor land management and conservation practices and attendant toxicities.  The result has been a desperate lot of African farmers left with an over-hyped crop with limited resilience to prevailing weather conditions against a background of neglected and underdeveloped alternative cereal crops. Today maize production is largely fluctuating and unpredictable. This has contributed to significant deficits in food production, high food prices, hunger and desperation (especially among the chronically poor).

Take Kenya for example, government policy has focused more on maize production giving lesser attention to alternative cereals.  The production of corn is significantly higher than sorghum and millet despite its highly erratic productivity. Folks have continued to invest in it and neglected the others anyway. Research and development, capacity and infrastructure towards sorghum have continued to lag behind other crops. Little has been done to educate farmers and to provide incentives to increase its production. Limited resources have been invested in improving its production, utilization, demand and marketing.



The return of Smart Sweet Sorghum:
Nonetheless people are gradually reverting to sorghum and in the most unusual places. In the past 2 decades, the area under sorghum cultivation has expanded, in fact almost doubled though production has not increased (still at 800Kg/ha on average). In urban areas, starred hotels today serve brown chapattis, millet/sorghum ugali/pap, and sorghum porridge. In addition, medical conditions are driving people away from maize to the good old smart sorghum for its nutritional content! Sorghum has also gained commercial significance in the malt and beer brewing industry where the private sector is increasingly contracting and facilitating farmers to produce sorghum commercially as a raw-material. The Nigerian brewing industry now consumes over 152,000 metric tonnes of sorghum annually. In East Africa, alcohol and beverage companies are providing incentives and subsidies to local populations to produce sorghum which is now a substitute for molasses in ethanol production. This is largely because the extract in the stalks of sorghum and the brown midrib produce high quality ethanol which is cheaper and more sustainable – compared molasses from sugarcane. New developments have capitalized on harnessing clean bio-energy from sorghum, which if effectively produced would provide a cheaper and cleaner alternative to fossil oil fuels. Sorghum is increasingly being harnessed to produce clean bio-fuels that could effectively help reduce foreign oil import costs, reduce green house gas emissions and mitigate the effects of other fuel sources on pollution and global warming. Indeed some of the billions of dollars paid to overseas oil producers can be effectively diverted to invest in and benefit poor rural communities producing sorghum based bio-fuels.

To cut my long story short. The evidence is overwhelming. You obviously do not need to be a rocket scientist to figure out how much Africa needs this crop. The loathing of subsistence agriculture helped by such delusional policies of transforming over a whole population of sedentary subsistence farmers into Agri-businessmen and women just won’t give us food. Isn’t it time governments stepped up agricultural policy and action towards reintroducing and revamping the productivity of this crop?

Wednesday, 12 September 2012


Vouching for Social Protection in East Africa: 
Mainstream development bypassing the extreme and chronically poor
Economic growth and policy response has been largely unsuccessful in adequately addressing issues that affect the poorest, most marginalised and vulnerable groups in East Africa, despite it being one of the world’s fastest growing regions today. Between 2000 and 2010 the size of East Africa’s economy more than doubled in real terms, from US$32 billion to US$79 billion. If Rwanda (currently growing at an average of 7.7%), Tanzania (6.8%) and Uganda (7.2%) maintain their growth momentum and Kenya (3.7%) accelerates, it is expected that they will reach middle-income status around 2022. Over the past decade average regional growth was estimated to be as high as 6.3%. Per capita incomes were US$1,061 which means that, in theory and on average, every East African was entitled to approximately US$88 a month or US$2.97 a day (more than double the  US$1.25  a day poverty line).
Yet despite its impressive economic growth trajectory, East Africa has remained one of the world’s poorest regions. According to the World Development Indicators and the Human Development Index 73% of the region’s population was living in multidimensional poverty in 2011; 52% of people were living below US$1.25 a day; and about 44% were living below nationally-defined poverty lines. In 2011, 135 of every 1,000 East African children died before their fifth birthday; 608 of every 100,000 women died in the process of giving birth; and nearly 58.4% of all East African children suffered from stunted growth.
Despite large investments in the areas of health, education and other public goods, barriers remain that preclude the poor from effectively and adequately accessing and utilising these resources. The chronically poor are often bypassed for a number of reasons. Firstly, mainstream development programmes operate on a large scale, meaning that nuances in the depth and diversity of poverty can be overlooked. Secondly, many state-led programmes assume that income alone can lift households out of poverty. Finally, the most deprived and vulnerable groups are often either unaware of government services, programmes and resources or lack the empowerment to demand for them.
Social protection presents a strategic opportunity to ensure that economic growth policies co-opt redistribution and respond to the problems and needs of the poorest. It aims to reduce social and economic risks and vulnerabilities, empower people in extreme poverty and guarantee a minimum standard of dignity for every individual throughout their life.
There is increasing awareness of the need to include social protection as a critical part of the mix of mainstream public goods that the state is obliged to provide and maintain. The Ouagadougou Summit (2004) vouched for enhanced coverage of effective and adequate social protection programmes across the continent. Through the Livingstone Call for Action (2006) fourteen participant countries committed to recognise social protection as a basic human right and integrate it into their developmental plans. The Social Protection Floor (2009) aims to support countries to plan and implement sustainable elements of social protection systems. In East Africa, constituent states are increasing efforts to institute coherent and coordinated social protection responses. Existing social protection programmes revolve around social security, hospital insurance, pension schemes, cash transfers and social assistance programmes.
However, the depth of social protection is still limited and fragmented in East Africa, which results in duplication and inefficiencies. Current social protection instruments do not reach a large section of the population (only about 10%). At the East African Community (EAC) level, little attention has been granted to establishing an East Africa-wide policy. Neither the EAC treaty (1999) nor the Common Market Protocol (2010) recognises social protection as a right, but merely as an aspect of social welfare. None of the countries in East Africa have ratified the ILO communication No 102 on social security (minimum standards) of 1952. Even the EAC strategic plan for Gender, youth, children, social protection and community development (2011-2015) portrays social protection in a narrow sense, focused on reducing vulnerability. With the exceptions of Kenya and Rwanda, most EAC states lack formal social protection policies and legislative provisions around recognising social protection as a right are vague.
There are marked variations amongst member states around the conceptualisation of social protection and levels of commitment, which highlights the need for minimum standards and comparability across the region. Stakeholder must now converge and explore avenues through which donors, governments and non-state actors can work actively towards embedding social protection as a critical part of the mix of mainstream services that every state in East Africa is obliged to provide and maintain.